Video - https://youtu.be/1-CZ6KCj2RA
Quiz - https://quizizz.com/join?gc=71351940
Key Points / Summary based on Recommended Book:
It can also be called three types of proofs or three levels of proofs
- Everyone looks for proofs.
- Proofs acts as a way to validation.
- Not all proofs are equal. Some proofs are better than the others.
Nichiren Daishonin Buddhism talks about three types or level of proofs to validate the teachings.
- Documentary Proof
- The basic doctrine / philosophy should be based on a textbook.
- The teachings or philosophy foundation must be based on a actual book and not based on any one person’s opinion or interpretation.
- This textbook must act as single source of truth.
- In case of any dispute or confusion, there has to be a textbook one can refer to and get clarification.
- Nichiren Daishonin states “ One should accept what is clearly stated in the text of the sutras, but discard anything that cannot be supported by the text”
- In Nichiren Daishonin Buddhism, this documentary proof is “Lotus Sutra” expounded by Shakyamuni Buddha himself !!
- For us in Soka Gakkai, Goshos, Writings of Nichiren Daishonin also acts as a documentary proof.
- Theoretical Proof
- Now, this is where according to me Nichiren Daishonin Buddhism stands out.
- So, next criteria to judge any philosophy is whether that religion’s doctrines and assertions are compatible with reason and logic.
- Buddhism is reason, rational and about logic.
- So this makes Nichiren Daishonin Buddhism stands out as it can be logically and rationally argued
- Actual Proof
- There is a saying in hindi - “Pratyaksh ko Praman Ki Kya Avshyakta”
- Means - Something which is very much apparent doesn’t need any proof.
- That is the most important criteria to judge any philosophy.
- As Nichiren Daishonin states - “In judging the relative merit of Buddhist doctrines, I, Nichiren, believe that the best standards are those of reason and documentary proof. And even more valuable than reason and documentary proof is the proof of actual fact”
- Actual proof means that if anyone has actually experienced the benefits, positive results in one’e life and how positively it has impacted people and society.
- Ultimately, no matter how solid or sound the documentary proof or theoretical proofs are, if it cannot be realistically applied in daily life or cannot product positive impact, then it is of no use.
- Best way to judge any religion is how it has positively impacted, made people happy, empowered in their daily life.
- This type of proof is called Actual proof.
So, if you ever need to judge any religion or philosophy, now you have got the framework
- Documentary Proof - Is it based on a text or opinion? Who wrote or expounded that book?
- Theoretical Proof - Can you logically and rationally argue the principles or need to shut your eyes / mind and accept the things even if it is in conflict of logic and reason
- Actual Proof - Can you see people who have got benefitted from it? People whose life positively impacted, became happier and better?
All three combined are important. It is not like that only 3 is important or only 2 is important.
All three are important and need to be checked to validate any philosophy or religion.